2

There have been several questions about web services and applications recently, and some have received close votes, so I think it'd be helpful to discuss whether these questions are on-topic for the site.

Some examples:

So, are these questions on-topic, or should they be closed (and, in future, potentially migrated to Web Applications if it is clear that these questions will not be on-topic here)?

2 Answers 2

5

I would add this question1 to the list of questions which in my mind are potentially mis-understanding the specific meaning of Internet of Things. Even without a specific, clear definition, we accept this term means something in the context of , , , , .

My example, and the Google email question seem, to me, fairly clearly off topic. There is nothing in these questions to give them a specific IoT context, they are simple things on the internet questions.

Questions about IoT cloud services seem on-topic, particularly the ones detailed in this answer. Various providers have come and come in this space in the past few years, as opposed to the more generic rent-a-server cloud offerings. If we want expert answers, we need questions which appeal to low-level developers.

Questions about an application of IFTTT are not automatically off-topic, although I imagine some questions might be borderline depending on the subject. More likely, I'd expect could attract too-broad questions or no-research rather than off-topic.


1: Question is deleted and is only visible with 4k reputation.

1
  • 1
    Using IFTTT to link various web services to each other is probably off-topic; using IFTTT to link hardware gadgets to web services is likely on-topic. Jan 11, 2017 at 16:29
2

This is a poorly stated question, as it imagines a category of "web services" that is entirely orthogonal to anything which matters for fitting into this this site - and groups three entirely distinct things for common attention, which they are simply too different to receive.

  • Rather obviously the google business email question is blatantly off topic.

  • "What IoT services are available for storing/sending/publishing generic data in the cloud?" is a site-related area, but pretty much all Stack Exchange sites reject as too broad questions which seek a list of what is out there - Stack Exchange sites are for questions that can have a specific answer, not for making lists.

  • "How delayed can IFTTT triggers be?" This seems like an IoT question, and at least from the title an appropriate one (though as in the previous go-around, not all IFTTT questions will be device related)

The diversity of answers for the three examples should demonstrate why it's hazardous to encourage thinking in terms of inapplicable categories - what matters not is if these are "web services", what matters is if they are about IoT and additionally if they are questions fitting the Stack Exchange model.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .